LegalTree.ca
Published on LegalTree.ca (https://www.legaltree.ca)

Home > SCC Decision: October 24, 2008

SCC Decision: October 24, 2008

Sun, 2008-10-26 18:21 — Andrew Pilliar
Taxonomy upgrade extras: 
SCC summaries by Andrew Pilliar [1]
Research articles : 
Criminal jury [2]

R. v. Rojas, 2008 SCC 56
Click here [3] to link to the full judgment.
(Criminal law / Jury charge)
Two brothers were convicted by a jury of second degree murder.  On appeal, they argued that the trial judge erred 1) in allowing the jury to use out-of-court statements admissible against one accused to bolster the credibility of an unsavoury witness with respect to the other accused, and 2) in instructing the jury that exculpatory statements did not carry the same weight as inculpatory statements.  The Court dismissed the appeal, finding that 1) the trial judge had given numerous cautions to try each individual separately and not use statements by one against the other, and that 2) the judge did not misdirect the jury.  The Court cautioned against instructing juries to give more weight to inculpatory statements than to exculpatory statements.
Majority/Dissent: 7/0

Copyright © 2007-2021 Legaltree Law Corporation.

Legaltree was founded by Michael Dew, a Vancouver lawyer and is owned and operated by Legaltree Law Corporation. 

Waiver of liability: All content on www.legaltree.ca is for information only and must not be relied on in any way. No legal advice is sought by browsing this site, and none is given. All links are provided for convenience only and no sites linked to are endorsed.


Source URL: https://www.legaltree.ca/node/1010

Links
[1] https://www.legaltree.ca/taxonomy/term/86
[2] https://www.legaltree.ca/taxonomy/term/123
[3] http://csc.lexum.umontreal.ca/en/2008/2008scc56/2008scc56.html